Long Way Home ~ Eva Dolan

w495038Given the number of posts I’ve written recently about crime fiction I (and, I suspect, you) have to ask whether there really is room in the market for yet another police procedural.  However, having just read Long Way Home, the first novel by Eva Dolan and publicised as the first in a new major series, I would have to say yes, because what Ms Dolan offers is not just a well written and extremely readable story but also one that does what the very best of crime fiction always does, that is throw a light on a social situation that is current, pressing and, to be honest, one that many of us would rather not acknowledge.

Long Way Home is set in Peterborough, a city so far from most people’s day in, day out, conscious experience that when I told an acquaintance about this book I had to explain to her where it was.  It is, however, a city that has seen considerable change over the past decade: change I have actually witnessed because I have friends who live nearby and it is their closest shopping centre. Always a hub of transient immigration because of the demand for agricultural workers in the nearby fen country, in more recent times it has seen this population grow and be augmented by immigrants, both legal and illegal, who are being lured here with false promises of jobs and homes by people bent only on exploiting them and treating them with unspeakable cruelty.  It isn’t, however, only those who deliberately set out to abuse these workers who have difficulty accepting them as valid members of society.  Many of those who have lived in the area for any length of time are also resentful of their presence, even if they only show it by moving away from the city centre into local villages. Consequently, while the crime that is being investigated at the start of this novel is that of murder, it is not a murder squad that is investigating it but rather Peterborough’s Hate Crime Unit, because the victim is thought to be an eastern European immigrant and the motive for his death one of racial hatred.

DI Zigic and DS Ferreira are called in when a burnt out shed proves to have been both home and final resting place to a body that is identified as Jann Stepulov, an itinerant worker who has been sleeping in the outhouse much to the anger of the Barlows on who grounds it is built.  DS Ferreira, herself an immigrant, is satisfied that the Barlows are responsible for the fire, seeing it as the simplest way to get rid of their unwanted tenant.  However, Zigic, of Polish stock but far less quick to judgment, is not so easily convinced and sets about looking for alternative evidence.  The further they dig into Stepulov’s background the more it becomes apparent that there are other people, both British and immigrant, who have reason to want him out of the way.  What they uncover is a network of gang-masters willing to exploit anyone who is seemingly friendless and without the resources to stand up for themselves, to the point of starvation and, if expedient, murder.  What they uncover is the type of situation that was brought forcible to public notice in the wake of the Morecambe Bay tragedy several years back when at least twenty-one immigrant cockle pickers were caught out by the incoming tide.

Brought to public notice, and yet, it still goes on.  The strength of Dolan’s novel is that she forces her reader to address a situation that is one I suspect many would rather just pretend isn’t happening and if it is, certainly isn’t any concern of theirs.  Initially I found myself bridling at Ferreira with her insistence that the British couple must be guilty because all Britons are prejudiced against immigrants.  “Excuse me,” I wanted to say, “er, pot, kettle, black.”  As the novel progress, however, all the characters, and the readers as well, have to question the easy assumptions that we make when we lump groups of people together and fail to treat them as individuals, and to accept that both great good and pure evil can reside in any human regardless of skin colour, creed or background.

This is a very strong first novel with leading characters who walk off the page already fully formed.  It has already excited the praise of critics and with good reason.  If I have one concern it is that Dolan may find it difficult to bring variety to the cases that she has Zigic and Ferreria investigate.  But, if she can avoid that issue then this has the potential to be the first in a series that will run and run.

With thanks to Random House UK, Vintage Publishing who made this available for review.


18 thoughts on “Long Way Home ~ Eva Dolan

  1. I really must look this book up. It is remarkable how the humble crime novel has evolved into a form that can, in a very flexible and hugely readable way, examine The Way We Live Now. So different from the days when theBritish Crime novel was characterized as “Snobbery With Violence”.

    1. Exactly, Ian. I was at a talk given by Lindsay Davis last week and she was making precisely that point about crime fiction when someone in the audience started to get snooty about literary fiction. By the way, you might like to go back to the post on Harry Bingham’s Love Story With Murders. Bingham has left a very long and friendly comment and invited responses. I’m sure he would like to hear what you think about what he has to say.

  2. This sounds like a brave first novel, tackling a subject that makes many of us uncomfortable, and very timely given the recent outburst of fear and prejudice over immigration from Eastern Europe. I hope it reaches a wide audience

    1. If I’m honest, Ali, I don’t think this is really your sort of book but if you feel like pushing the boundaries then you won’t be disappointed by the standard of the writing.

  3. Oh my, I live close to Peterborough and it is always in the news at the moment, either as one of the fastest growing towns or one of the most troubled. The police recently cracked a sexual abuse ring that they thought was one of the largest, most violent and most disturbing they’d come across. So a crime novel set in Peterborough sounds like a very good idea. Like you, I think that the best crime has social comment at its heart, and youve certainly made me keen to try this one.

    1. I think you’d find this really interesting especially as you know the area, Litlove. You might also be interested to go to my slightly earlier review of Harry Bingham’s crime novel, Love Story With Murders. The author has left a long and friendly comment on what I and others have said and invited responses. I’m sure he would be interested in your thoughts.

  4. Unfortunately Houston, where I live, is an immigration hub, and we see cases like the ones these officers would be investigating all too often. I agree with Ian above, about the evolution of crime novels. Hopefully this book (and sequels) will make it to the US.

      1. I’ve just re-read my comment & realized I phrased it badly. I didn’t mean it’s unfortunate that we are an immigration hub, but unfortunate that we see these situations.

    1. That’s the way it’s being publicised, Stefanie. I certainly want to read more of her work because she writes so well. I just hope the situation she’s set up gives her sufficient variety to maintain a series.

  5. This certainly sounds good, Alex. I look forward to it coming out here. I’ve just checked Amazon, and while it’s out in hardcover now, the paperback is due this summer. Hurray! I’ve got it on my list now 🙂 I really enjoyed your review. Immigration and immigrants and jobs is always a touchy subject, no matter where you live, especially due to the economic problems of the past few years. I know in England, the flood of Eastern Europeans into the UK has been a problem. Quite a few mysteries are featuring this subject now – Stuart Neville (Stolen Souls) – just because I have it here on my pile to read! – and I can’t think of others at the moment, but there are several. Mysteries are good for opening the lid off to peer underneath at what society might possibly think and be doing in areas no one wants to really know about. Your review covers this so well, Alex. Do you think that mysteries – and police procedurals as well as single detectives working against the system – are our way of beginning to look at these situations? I do.

    1. I was going to suggest that you look at the comments on the Bingham post, Susan, but I see you’ve found it by yourself. I do think that crime fiction has always been a way of forcing the public to address those sides of society that we would rather ignore. Whether it takes a maverick working against the system to do that, I’m not sure. I do think that some of those mavericks are becoming so extreme as to no longer be believable and if they’re not believable then neither is the fact that they defeat the bad guys – which is worrying. I want to believe the bad guys can be caught.

Your thoughts are welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s