Losing the Plot: Bones of the Lost ~ Kathy Reich

8359861_0_9999_lge_v1_m56577569854304873There is a small number of writers whose works I automatically put on order as soon as a new novel is announced.  These are authors I have followed, in many instances, since their earliest publications and who I have always been able to rely on as excellent story-tellers.  Some of them are authors of what might loosely be termed general fiction, while others are crime writers.  I maintain two separate lists.  However, more and more often I am finding that the authors on that second list are falling short of my expectations and gradually their numbers are beginning to dwindle.

I suspect you won’t need me to enumerate the reasons behind this, most significant of which, I think, is the demand (from both publishers and readers) that these writers produce a book a year.  Sometimes the writing of a book just takes longer and, frustrating as we readers might find it, for the sake of quality we should be prepared to wait.  After all, if the book has been rushed we are just as likely to be frustrated by what we do read as we would have been by, say, an eighteen month gap between novels.

I remember one notorious instance where the only way the author could explain what the villain of the piece had been up to was to have his detective confront the evildoer in his office and spell it out to him.  Excuse me, but he didn’t need to be told what he’d done.  He had, after all, done it. Normally we would have stood by and watched while the police pieced together bit by bit the nefarious dealings of said villain, but clearly publication date was pressing and so instead what we got was a ploy which was not that far removed from the formula beloved by school children everywhere, and then I woke up and it was all a dream.

While not quite so lacking in subtlety, I’m afraid that Kathy Reichs most recent Tempe Brennan novel, Bones of the Lost, displays similar signs of having been put together far too quickly and when I compare it to her earliest books it disappoints in respect of detail and coherence as well as pushing coincidence to a point where I find I can no longer suspend disbelief.

Briefly, because I don’t want to give too much away if you haven’t already read it, Brennan finds herself tied up with what appear to be two completely unrelated cases.  One concerns the death of a young woman in a hit and run accident on the outskirts of Charlotte, while the other takes the forensic anthropologist to Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan to oversee the exhumation of two bodies that are at the centre of a potential court martial.  Either of these would have made an interesting book in their own right because each of them deals with an issue that is current and deserves to be given a public airing.  It is because Reich tackles subjects that in many cases the powers-that-be would rather sweep under the carpet that I continue to read her.  However, focusing on both problems weakens the impact that a deeper exploration of either one of them would have had and the way in which they just happen to come together stretches the reader’s credulity beyond my tolerance point.

Am I then saying that this will be the last book in this series that I read?  Ah, well, that’s where the hook comes in.  I’ve written before about my conviction that in many instances we read novels that are part of crime series as much to follow the personal lives of the officers concerned as to discover the solution to the current mystery and Reichs is certainly a writer who recognises this.  There are two carefully placed scenes which move Brennan’s personal life forward on separate but related paths.  However, neither of them resolve the situation they advance, thus tantalisingly demanding that the reader come back for succeeding episodes to find out what happens next.  It takes the art of closing each chapter on a cliffhanger to a whole new level.  I’d like to think that I can resist that carefully placed hook.  After all, I know that any future novel will be just as carefully and enticingly constructed.  But whether or not I have the strength of will is something you will have to come back next year to find out.  If I am writing about another Reichs mystery you’ll know I gave into temptation.


9 thoughts on “Losing the Plot: Bones of the Lost ~ Kathy Reich

  1. I haven’t read all of the Bones series just a few of the earlier ones. I too think we suffer with the pressure to pull off a novel a year – I’d rather wait and get a fully rounded story. Sorry that you were disappointed.

    1. There are so many good writers out there that it isn’t as if we’re going to be short of reading material, but I do think readers are as much to blame as publishers. If we said more often we were willing to wait perhaps they’d listen.

      1. Yes as much as I long to get the next fix from my favourites my shelves are bulging with new authors and books to be discovered. I think the publishers need to ask the question in their surveys as a matter of course. A good point to make though, it happens a lot with successful debuts too.

  2. I also would rather wait and get a decent book. As Cleopatra says, it’s not as if any of us are short of books! I reviewed a debut book a couple of years back and thought it was great. Within the next couple of years, the autor brought out three more, each worse than the one before – obviously trying to cash in on the relative success of Book 1, but all it really did was make people like me take him promptly back off the ‘must read’ list.

    1. That is a shame because, while there certainly are writers who only have one book in them, if he’d only taken the time with a second book that he must have given to the first then there might have been a long career there.

  3. Too bad about this one feeling so rushed. I know what you mean though about the difficulty of giving up on a series. It’s like a relationship gone bad and you just can’t believe it and want to leave but can’t quite because you still remember when things were so good. Best of luck next year 🙂

    1. Yes, that’s exactly it, Stefanie. I feel as if someone on whom I have come to rely has let me down and I’ll never be quite able to trust them again.

  4. I confess I haven’t read Kathy Reichs although I do intend to (my dad likes her a lot). I know exactly what you mean about books being rushed. I loved the early Lee Child novels about Jack Reacher, but the later ones haven’t been anywhere near as good. The poor man is forced to bring out two books a year, so no wonder. You’d think he’d make enough money for his publishers with just the one!

    1. If you do try Reichs start at the beginning. The first book goes a little over the top with the forensic detail, but it’s still better than what she is writing today. The second, third and fourth are where she really comes into her own.

Your thoughts are welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s